-->

For all our KMWorld friends - register NOW for London's KMWorld Europe 2026 & save £300 with the code HOLIDAYS. 
 Offer ends 31 December 2025.

Why Embodied Knowledge Matters and Why AI Doesn't Understand

Article Featured Image

As more and more of our knowledge—certainly mine—comes from non-human, bodiless entities that have never smelled fresh air, taken a shower, or asked for more strawberry syrup at the local pancake restaurant, we should stay awake to the importance of embodiment to knowledge.

For a very long time, we in the West saw the physical body as an impediment to knowing, as anyone who has stayed up all night writing a term paper can attest. Rationality needs an alert mind, a quiet room, and a chair so comfortable that you don’t even notice it.

In 1637, Descartes wistfully recalled the day about 20 years earlier when he had been struck by a vision of a science built on an unshakeable foundation. “I remained for an entire day shut up by myself in a stove-heated room, where I was completely free to converse with myself about my thoughts.” How lovely! Of course, 20 years later, a different quiet room led him to imagine that the only thing he knew for sure was that he was thinking. From that he managed to deduce that he had a body. Hence the famous, “I think, therefore I am.”

Descartes’ problem with bodies is that they are unreliable conduits of what’s real. Perhaps you once stuck a stick into water and it looked broken or you mistook an overcooked potato chip for a mouse.

Limitations of Physical Bodies

Beyond that, bodies come with severe limitations. For example, think how much smarter we humans would be if we had eyes on either side of our heads like whales do. Twice as much information coming in! Two simultaneous perspectives! Even better, imagine if we were nothing but eyes, facing in every possible direction. (Note to self: Where to put the ears?)

Finally, in the 20th century, the notion that our bodies have something important to contribute to thinking began to be taken seriously. Martin Heidegger’s 1927 book, Being and Time, proposed the radical idea that being embodied meant you’ve already been “thrown” into some era, speaking a particular language, in a particular body, raised by particular adults. In short, embodiment means you’re situated in a place, time, and culture. No one can entirely think themselves out of their sit- uation because that situation forms their thinking.

Yet more scandalous: Not only does your situatedness shape your thinking, it’s the condition for thinking at all. Being conscious without having any of the scaffolding your situation gives you would leave you like a baby assaulted by sensations you couldn’t make sense of. The view from nowhere is of nothing.

In 1966, Michael Polanyi’s book, Tacit Dimension, took the bodily connection to knowing further: Our bodies know much that our minds do not: Your legs know how to walk, your hands know when pie crust is ready to be rolled, your butt knows how to prepare for a bump you can see in the road ahead. It’s always amazing to me that even though I’ve been a touch typist for over 60 years, I don’t know where all the keys are. Luckily, my fingers do.

KMWorld Covers
Free
for qualified subscribers
Subscribe Now Current Issue Past Issues